• Loading stock data...
Tuesday December 24, 2024

A Seasoned Perspective

  • College sports reform neither began nor ends with amateurism.
  • FOS surveyed a few seasoned college sports reformers for their thoughts on the ruling.
football_player_running
Photo: Alabama Athletics/Design: Alex Brooks

Many of Monday’s reactions made it sound like the battle for college sports reform ended with the Alston ruling. But the fight to fix NCAA exploitation neither began nor ended with Alston.

A cadre of college sports reformers have been fighting the NCAA in court and working on alternative models for years, if not decades. They provided a more seasoned perspective to FOS.

To them, the ruling brings cautious optimism. But everyone agreed that, as economist Andy Schwarz said, “A next step is needed.”

A Little Vindication

Schwarz and fellow economist Daniel Rascher have been studying the NCAA since the late 1990s, and were involved not just in NCAA v. Alston, but also O’Bannon v. NCAA and White v. NCAA.

Back in the ‘90s, “I naively figured we’d be where we are today after about 5-10 years,” Rascher said. 

Schwarz said that since then, “I have had all sorts of people tell me that college athletes are not, in fact, entitled to the same market freedoms as other adults. It is somewhat validating to have nine Supreme Court justices say they actually are.”

Like the others, Ricky Volante, lawyer and CEO of the Professional Collegiate League (which Schwarz also helped co-found), was happy to see the decision. But he won’t be doing a victory lap anytime soon. 

“College athletes deserve to be recognized and treated as full-fledged citizens, which means receiving a salary plus benefits (not just more perks), the right to unionize, the right to collectively bargain, and more,” he said. “Until we reach that point, I’ll personally find it difficult to celebrate this decision or flawed NIL bills going into effect.”

Reassessing the System

“I still believe it will take outside forces to get athletes their full rights, and the full set of options they deserve,” Schwarz said. Schwarz and Volante are in favor of budding organizations like theirs that will treat players like employees.

David Ridpath, an Ohio University sports management professor and former president of The Drake Group, was optimistic. But as for next steps, “As The Drake Group has been advocating — it is time to take a serious look at this system via a presidential commission … and reassess the purpose and place of educationally based elite sport development in our country,” he said.

More lawsuits are also possible. And so is pushing NIL rights further.

Linkedin
Copy Link
Link Copied
Link Copied

What to Read

ESPN College GameDay Means More to Schools Than a Saturday Morning Spotlight

Schools reap ‘immeasurable’ benefits when the ESPN bus rolls into town.
NCAA

NCAA’s Witness In Gee Trial Denies That Football Causes CTE

Former NCAA medical committee member James Puffer said the evidence isn’t “irrefutable.”

How USC Star QB Caleb Williams Evaluates NIL Deals

He looks for brands that he can forge a “genuine relationship” with.

The U.S. Olympic and Paralympic Governing Body Getting Into NIL

USA Triathlon is the first NGB to organize and facilitate an NIL collective.
podcast thumbnail mobile
Front Office Sports Today

Are Legacy Games Hurting NFL Thanksgiving?

0:00
0:00

Featured Today

Commanders Sale Could Hit $7B, Durant Wants In

A Washington Commanders sale could be wrapped up by the spring.
November 6, 2022

How the Astros Won the World Series Without Breaking the Bank

The Astros won the World Series with underpriced talent.
kyrie-irving-nike
November 4, 2022

Nike Suspends Relationship With Kyrie Irving Over Antisemitism

After several days of silence, the brand has dropped Irving.
Washington-Commanders
November 4, 2022

Bezos, Jay-Z Reportedly Teaming Up on Commanders Bid

Jeff Bezos and Jay-Z are frontrunners to be the next NFL owners.

Careers

Powered By

Careers in Sports

Looking for a new job? Check out these featured listings and search for openings all over the world with Jobbio.
Sr. Account Manager
Miami Heat
Miami, FL
Director of Ads
Nike
Portland, OR – Hybrid
Sports Journalist
CBS Sports
New York City, NY

CTE Expert Says NCAA Concussion Education Is Insufficient

“There still needs to be way more education for the athlete.”
Sponsored

Big 12 Could Add Another Basketball Powerhouse

The Big 12 could bolster its membership by adding a mid-major.
October 31, 2022

Trial Reveals NCAA Knew About Head Injury Risks As Early As 1930s

The NCAA was aware of these dangers, but took years to act.
October 28, 2022

Trial Data Suggests The NCAA Failed to Invest in Health and Safety

The NCAA spent less than 1% of earnings on a medical committee.
October 28, 2022

Drew Timme Is Using NIL To Secure His Future

Timme is launching a podcast in his senior season.
October 26, 2022

NCAA’s New NIL Rules Prohibit Schools From Negotiating Deals

The NCAA’s newest NIL guidance appears to create completely new rules.
(NCAA-Congress)
October 26, 2022

Lawyers Allege NCAA Documents Related To Head Injuries Have ‘Disappeared’

Plaintiff lawyers alleged the NCAA intentionally hid or disposed of them.
October 24, 2022

LSU Is the Latest School to Be Fined For A Postgame Celebration

Some of the most iconic college football celebrations have a price.